November 21, 2024 | Jack Hawkins

The Most Valuable Vintage Toys Of All Time


The Most Valuable Vintage Toys Of All Time

Do you remember Beanie Babies? Or the original run of Star Wars action figures? Many toys tend to lose their value as we damage them, or they get taken out of the box accidentally and therefore immediately depreciate. 

But rare ones—those that remain boxed or otherwise in pristine condition—could be worth a small fortune. Here are the most valuable vintage toys of all time.

Rss Thumb - Vintage Toys

Simon Memory Game

The Simon Memory Game may bring back some fond memories for some—others, not so much. If you still have one of these memory order games kicking around, you could be looking at a cool $50 value.

Simon Says Memory GameWilton Taylor, Flickr

Advertisement

Bop It!

Could you bop it, twist it, smack it back in the day? Released in the mid-90s, vintage Bop Its sell today for $100.

Bop-It Extreme 2 Green Side ToyMatthuxtable, Wikimedia Commons

Lite Brite

Lite Brite was released in 1967. They allowed kids to put colored pegs into an illuminated board and make shapes and animals out of them. While most of these small pegs got lost over the years, if you have a full set, you could be looking at a sale price of around $100

Photo of  Lite-Brite toythomas ambridge, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Digimon Cards

While Digimon was always going to struggle to rival Pokémon, the card game still caught on like wildfire for those looking for something different. Rare packs of cards today can go for well over $100.

Picture of English Digimon cardsSimbert Brause, Shutterstock

Advertisement

Easy-Bake Ovens

Easy-Bake Ovens inspired the baker in us all! One of the best-selling toys of the 1960s could today fetch you $150. Although, hopefully by now you've graduated to a full-size oven, it'll never beat the Easy-Bake.

The first versions of Easy-Bake ovenBradross63, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Nintendo Gameboy

Before there were hand-held cellphones, there were Gameboys. Nintendo Gameboys were the best thing since sliced bread in the late 1990s/early 2000s. Whiling away the hours on them after school was just the done thing. Some of the original Gameboy consoles can fetch about $250 on EBay.

A handheld game console GameboyWilliam Warby, Flickr

Vintage Playmobil

Most of us can remember Playmobil from our childhoods—the articulating creations of a German manufacturer took the toy world by storm. Vintage sets, such as a Victorian Doll House or Knight's Castle from 1995 sold for $350 each online.

A group of vintage Playmobil cowboysonly_point_five, Flickr

Advertisement

Super Soaker Water Guns

How many of you longed for one of the Super Soakers to drench your sibling or parents with? I'm sure we all did at some point. Well, now you can find one (or sell yours!) for between $100 and $500.

Purple Super Soaker water gunUnknown Author, Wikimedia Commons

Troll Dolls

Trolls were the cute little dolls with big eyes and wacky hair. First created in 1956 and hugely popular from the 1970s till the 1990s, Troll dolls can fetch between $200 and $400 today. I suppose it beats the dog using them as a chew toy.

Three vintage Troll dollsHoboh Official, Flickr

Original Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle Action Figures

If you were a kid in the 1980s, chances are you remember attending the Ninja Turtle-themed birthday party of one of your friends. They were everywhere, and so were the action figurines—now, one in good condition will fetch about $500.

Ninja Turtle Action Figures~ tOkKa, Flickr

Advertisement

Vintage Colorforms

Colorforms were cool vinyl-cut, sticky-backed adhesives that you could stick to an adhesive surface to make pictures and shapes. Old-school colorforms have recently experienced a huge uptick in popularity, with some fetching between $400 and $700

Mickey Mouse Fun House ColorformsJim, the Photog, Flickr

Original Lionel Train Sets

Lionel train sets were popular electronic toys in the early 20th century. Some of the original Lionel train sets are now worth hundreds, some even selling for as much as $700, particularly those released before the Second World War.

Original Lionel Train SetsZachary578, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

First Furbies

You remember those cute-but-very-annoying little toys that took the world by storm in the late 1990s. Furbies today, if in an unopened original box, can fetch as much $900.

Retro pink Furby toyVeronica Winters, Shutterstock

Advertisement

Lego Trains

Lego trains were one of Lego's greatest innovations—combining two passions of millions of people was a marketing masterstroke and today, each set of Lego trains goes for between $400 and $1,000.

One section of a massive LEGO trainSean Lamb, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Collections Of Happy Meal Toys

McDonald's' menu hasn't changed that much, but the value of their Happy Meal toys has. Vintage collections of all of the Disney lineup, for example, are priced around $1,000. Or, you can buy individual toys for about $30.00. Now is a good time to offload a full set of your old Happy Meal toys, if you still have them.

Monster - Hotel Transylvania Collections of Happy Meal Toysmonstersforsale, Flickr

Vintage Marble Sets

If you lost your marbles, you may be out of luck, as these sets can fetch upwards of $1,200.

Colorful Marble SetsChristian Schnettelker, Flickr

Advertisement

Garbage Pail Kids Collectible Cards

It may not sound like a particularly enticing toy, but Garbage Pail Kids cards were all the rage in the surrealist 1980s—I mean, who wouldn't want a card with a character named "Peg Leg Greg" on it? One, named after the "Adam Bomb" character, fetched $1,550 at auction. The average price is around $1,000, with bonus points if they're in their original packaging.

Garbage Pail Kids' Collectible CardsJelene Morris, Flickr

American Girls "Molly" Doll

For most of us, dolls are creepy. But, for collectors, they can be a gold mine. Produced in 1986 by the Pleasant Company, the "American Girl" doll line included Molly, Kirsten, Samantha, and Felicity. Each of them are now considered to be "out of print". Well, Molly recently fetched $3,000 at auction.

American Girl Jim, the Photog, Flickr

Mario Kart 64

Ah, Mario Kart 64—one of the best-selling video games of all-time. If you happen to be in possession of an original, sealed copy of it, you'll likely be able to sell it for $4,000. Unsealed copies can also go for a few hundred.

A closeup view of a Nintendo 64 game consoleThe Image Party, Shutterstock

Advertisement

Raggedy Ann Doll

Raggedy Ann Dolls were a doll caricature based on the character created by Johnny Gruelle in 1915 and introduced to the public in the 1918 book series written by Gruelle. Today, Raggedy Ann dolls that began production in 1920 can fetch up to $4,500.

Raggedy Ann Dollsellenm1. Flickr

Teddy Ruxpin 

Released in 1985, Teddy Ruxpin revolutionized bedtime storytelling for children (and parents)! With an audio cassette tape in its back, Teddy recounted his adventures to many a sleepy child. Today? The lovable storytelling bear can be had for $5,000, if it's an original. If not, a mere $500. 

An electronic children's toy Teddy RuxpinWade Tregaskis, Flickr

Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Baby

While Beanie Babies have been a huge hit over the decades since Ty Inc launched them in 1986, the Peanut Royal Blue Elephant was actually a mistake in the manufacturing process. They turned out a darker shade than originally intended and thus only 2,000 were produced. 

It's the most collectible Beanie Baby in existence, worth around $5,000. That's more than a Princess Diana-inspired Beanie Baby.

Baby Ty plush elephant toyM Outdoors, Shutterstock

Advertisement

My Little Ponies

My Little Ponies were flying off the shelves in the early 1980s and today, those collections are worth bank—if you collected a vintage Little Pony, you could be looking at $6,000 for just one of them.

Two My Little PoniesSue Thompson, Flickr

A First Edition Harry Potter And The Sorcerer's Stone 

Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone was first published in 1998, and finding a first edition today would be quite the task. But if you were one of the people who got your hands on one, you could have a $6,500 book just sitting on the shelf.

A First Edition Harry Potter And The Sorcerer's StoneEnglish PEN, Flickr

Nintendo Gamecube

If you have an OG Gamecube that still functions, then your vintage early-2000s console could fetch as much as $7,000 online. Some may even be worth more. 

Vintage Nintendo GameCubeJoe Haupt, Flickr

Advertisement

First-Edition Barbie Doll

Did you know that Barbie Dolls weren't originally pink-clad blondes? The original Barbie doll from 1959 wore a striped dress with a sweeping hairstyle, black heels, and white sunglasses. Owning one of these pieces of Barbie history will cost you an astonishing $8,000.

Boxed Reproduction BarbieSpeckledOwl, Flickr

GI Joe Action Figures

GI Joe may have been everyone's favorite toy if they ever dreamed of being a soldier. Released in 1964, the figurines have continued their extreme popularity, with individual figures running from $8,000 right up to $200,000 for a 1963 prototype version. 

Original 1964 GI Joe Action FigureMike Mozart, Flickr

Boba Fett Action Figurine

Boba Fett is one of the most beloved Star Wars characters, with the bounty hunter fetching as much as $32,000 for an in-box, mint condition figurine. Boba Fettch my wallet.

Boba Fett and Luke SkywalkerHannaford, Flickr

Advertisement

Magic: The Gathering Trading Cards

Magic: The Gathering is a bonafide cult classic card game. Old collections have sold for tens of thousands of dollars, with the rarest of individual cards selling for as much as $87,000.

A man is playing in board game Magic: The GatheringStock-Photo, Shutterstock

Luke Skywalker Action Figurine

If you happen to have an original, boxed Star Wars action figurine, you're in for some serious coin. One such figure from 1978 was offloaded by Japanese designer, Nigo, to Sotheby's for $25,000 in 2015. It's one of only 20 1978 Skywalker action figurines out there.

Original Star Wars action figure: Luke SkywalkerChris Murphy, Flickr

We've Found Out Where The Wild Things Are

Maurice Sendak's iconic children's book Where The Wild Things Are was a hugely popular picture book that was adapted into a short film in 1973, an opera in 1980, and a 2009 live-action movie. The original picture book? A signed first-edition copy sold for $25,000 online.

Children's book Mike Mozart, Flickr

Advertisement

Optimus Prime Is Primely Priced

The original Transformers action figures were produced by Hasbro in 1984, with many being torn from their boxes in seconds. But if you were insightful enough as a child, or simply didn't care for your brand-new Optimus Prime Transformer, you could now be staring at $25,000. A *transformational* sum, you might say.

Optimus Prime G1 Cartoon Style Robot ReplicafrogDNA, Flickr

PEZ Dispensers

If you loved your PEZ dispenser back when they were all the rage, and you kept it around for posterity's sake, you'll be delighted to know that it may be worth something. The most valuable PEZ dispenser was the Astronaut B, created for the World Bank Fair in 2006—it sold for a shocking $32,000. Enough to pay for all the dentistry you'd need after chucking back PEZ candies like they were going out of fashion. 

Pez Dispenser CollectionKenneth Lu, Flickr

Rear-Loading Beach Bomb Hot Wheel

This rear-loading cargo-style van Hot Wheel that's almost VW-esque in its appearance—except for the hot pink coloring—was a prototype designed by Mattel that remained in the possession of a Mattel employee for years. 

Unfortunately, the "Beach Bomb" proved to be too unstable to run as a regular product, but its rarity accounts for a staggering $40,000 price tag.

Hot Wheels CollectionPhil's 1stPix, Flickr

Advertisement

The OG Monopoly Board Game

Nowadays, there are so many different versions of Monopoly that it's difficult to keep track, but the original Monopoly Board Game, created in 1933 by Charles Darrow—those original boards were hand-drawn on oil cloth—may be worth some cash. 

The original board owned by Darrow sold for $146,000 at Sotheby's in 2011. Even some of the first boards in circulation could be worth over $3,000.

Monopoly Board GameRich Brooks, Flickr

Cabbage Patch Kids Dolls

If 18" dolls aren't your thing, then Cabbage Patch Kids Dolls might have been. The adorable little dolls were created in 1978 by Xavier Roberts and quickly amassed a cult following. Joe and Pat Prosey own the world's largest collection of Cabbage Patch dolls—over 5,000 of them in their custom-built Maryland museum. The price tag for all of them? $360,000.  

Cloth dolls with plastic heads - Cabbage Patch Kidsfishhawk, Flickr

Superman's Introductory Comic Book

Action Comics first introduced Superman to the world back in 1938. And it was this introductory comic book in pristine condition on EBay that sold for an astonishing $3.2 million. It was one of less than 50 in existence worldwide.

Superman statue and illustrations of the comic bookChoo Yut Shing, Flickr

Advertisement

Pokémon Cards

Pokémon Cards were a huge part of most of our childhoods. Today, some of the ultra-rare ones can be found on EBay for upwards of a million dollars. Some are as high as $6,000,000

Small collection of shiny Pokemon cardsMinh Hoang, Flickr

The Atari Urban Legend

There was an old urban legend that the Atari video game company had buried hundreds of their video game cartridges in the New Mexico desert in 1983. It turned out to be completely true—almost 1,300 of them were recovered. Nowadays, rare Atari games go for a few hundred dollars on Ebay.

Excavating and finding Atari E.T. video gameTaylorhatmaker, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons


READ MORE

successful

Successful People Share Their 'Easy Money' Secrets

Having a little extra cash at the end of the day is never a bad thing, right? Successful people answer “What is your way of making ‘easy money’?"
April 7, 2021 Eul Basa
112

Rich People Share The Easiest Way To Make Over $100K a Year

While many people live pay-check to pay-check, there are those who are able to earn over over $100K a year. Here are their stories.
May 21, 2019 Eul Basa
1

Dishonest People Confess The Most Unethical Way They've Made Money

We searched the web for the most unethical ways people have made money and the answers have been both hilarious and frightful.
April 7, 2021 Eul Basa
123123123

Regretful People Share The Most Expensive Mistake They've Ever Made

Often the biggest mistakes we make are the ones that end up teaching us the most. We ask the Internet, “What's the most expensive mistake you've ever made?”
September 16, 2018 Eul Basa
easymoney

The Biggest Money Mistakes People Are Making, As Told By Successful Savers

Whether we step in or not, watching other people make silly money mistakes can be frustrating, especially if you've made those same mistakes. 
August 25, 2018 Eul Basa



Dear reader,


It’s true what they say: money makes the world go round. In order to succeed in this life, you need to have a good grasp of key financial concepts. That’s where Moneymade comes in. Our mission is to provide you with the best financial advice and information to help you navigate this ever-changing world. Sometimes, generating wealth just requires common sense. Don’t max out your credit card if you can’t afford the interest payments. Don’t overspend on Christmas shopping. When ordering gifts on Amazon, make sure you factor in taxes and shipping costs. If you need a new car, consider a model that’s easy to repair instead of an expensive BMW or Mercedes. Sometimes you dream vacation to Hawaii or the Bahamas just isn’t in the budget, but there may be more affordable all-inclusive hotels if you know where to look.


Looking for a new home? Make sure you get a mortgage rate that works for you. That means understanding the difference between fixed and variable interest rates. Whether you’re looking to learn how to make money, save money, or invest your money, our well-researched and insightful content will set you on the path to financial success. Passionate about mortgage rates, real estate, investing, saving, or anything money-related? Looking to learn how to generate wealth? Improve your life today with Moneymade. If you have any feedback for the MoneyMade team, please reach out to [email protected]. Thanks for your help!


Warmest regards,

The Moneymade team